This Day in Boxing History: Muhammad Ali vs. Sonny Liston and Decades Later Shane Mosley vs. Fernando Vargas

This Day in Boxing History: Muhammad Ali vs. Sonny Liston and Decades Later Shane Mosley vs. Fernando Vargas

Few fights in boxing history resonate across generations like Muhammad Ali vs. Sonny Liston (1964–1965) and Shane Mosley vs. Fernando Vargas (2006). Though separated by four decades, each clash reflected its moment; one defining a heavyweight’s rise during a period of social upheaval, the other a crossroads for two elite light middleweights seeking redemption and relevance.

Cassius Clay (Muhammad Ali) vs Sonny Liston

On February 25, 1964, a 22-year-old Cassius Clay entered Miami Beach Convention Center to challenge Sonny Liston, the reigning heavyweight champion. Liston, a fearsome knockout artist who had demolished former champion Floyd Patterson in a first-round finish, was widely feared as arguably the most intimidating man in boxing. Clay, by contrast, was brash, fast, and underestimated, having won Olympic gold in 1960 but with little professional respect. Against expectation, he danced, jabbed, and frustrated Liston’s power round after round. When Liston failed to answer the bell for the seventh round, Clay was crowned world heavyweight champion.

The rematch, held on May 25, 1965, in Lewiston, Maine, became infamous for the “phantom punch,” a lightning-quick right hand that floored Liston in the first round. Ali himself later reflected, “The punch jarred him. It was a good punch, but I didn’t think I hit him so hard that he couldn’t have gotten up.” That was the knockout that has fascinated generations, highlighting Ali’s blend of speed and timing. Together, the bouts launched Ali into global prominence, setting the stage for fights with Joe Frazier, George Foreman, and countless others, and solidifying his role as a cultural as well as sporting icon.

Shane Mosley vs Fernando Vargas

Fast-forward to Saturday, February 25, 2006, at the Mandalay Bay Events Center in Las Vegas. Shane Mosley, already a three-division world champion, faced Fernando Vargas in a WBA light middleweight title eliminator billed simply as “Showdown.” Both men carried histories of championship glory; Mosley with speed and technical finesse, Vargas with raw power and aggressive intent. Both men sought redemption amid career challenges. From the opening bell, the fight unfolded as a tactical war. Vargas pressed forward but soon found his vision compromised by swelling around his left eye, which Mosley had systematically targeted with crisp combinations. By the tenth round, referee Joe Cortez stopped the fight at 1:22, awarding Mosley a TKO victory. Judges’ scorecards prior to the stoppage reflected a tight contest: two favored Mosley by a point, one favored Vargas by the same margin.

The fighters’ reactions captured the personal stakes of the battle. Vargas said afterward, “I was wondering why they stopped the fight… I was the one pushing the action, backing him into the ropes. I definitely want a rematch. Let’s see what he says.” He added, “He knows I was winning. The world knows I was winning. I was winning with one eye.” Mosley, ever the tactician, reflected on the physical battle: “Before I knew it, his eye was swollen like a balloon… as the rounds went on, it got bigger and bigger, and I went, ‘Wow, look what we have here.’” Mosley earned approximately $3 million plus percentages of the PPV for that fight, while Vargas earned around $4 million.

Ali–Liston and Mosley–Vargas share the central truth that a collision of styles creates defining moments. Ali’s first victory over Liston was tactical brilliance by a young challenger, while the second fight’s brevity and controversy over the phantom punch continue to captivate analysts and fans. Mosley vs. Vargas was a fight of attrition and adaptation; precision and conditioning overcoming raw aggression. The fight confirmed Mosley’s enduring skill and highlighted Vargas’ resilience.

Ali’s triumph over Liston kick-started a reign that became the cultural and athletic benchmark for heavyweights. Mosley’s technical victory over Vargas reaffirmed his status as one of the most gifted junior middleweights of his era and offered a masterclass in methodical, intelligent boxing.

To comment on this article in the Fight Forum, please CLICK HERE