Featured Articles
The Taylor-Catterall Brouhaha is Mindful of Another ‘Injustice’
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/72695/72695d55e7c97ea3d847754115eda247181f0a4f" alt="The-Taylor-Catterall-Brouhaha-is-Mindful-of-Another-Injustice"
On Feb. 26, unified 140-pound world champion Josh Taylor retained all of his belts with a split decision over Jack Catterall before a sellout crowd at the OVO Hydro arena in Glasgow, Scotland. As bad decisions go, this was hardly one of the worst of all time — not even close – but it ranks among the worst of all time in terms of the backlash. One would have to go back 30 years to find a decision that caused such a big stink.
On Feb. 8, 1992, James “Lights Out” Toney successfully defended his IBF world middleweight title with a split decision over David Tiberi at the Trump Taj Mahal in Atlantic City. One of the judges had Tiberi winning by a 117-111 score, but he was out-voted by his colleagues who both had it 115-112 for Toney. There were no knockdowns but the referee took a point away from Tiberi in round six for a low blow.
The verdict sparked a federal investigation. The spearhead, as one might have guessed, was a politician from Tiberi’s own district, namely Sen. William V. Roth Jr. of Delaware. Roth, who watched the fight on television, decried the decision as “outrageous” on the Senate floor while setting the wheels in motion for an investigation that he hoped would lead to the establishment of a federal boxing commission.
Sen. Roth re-appeared this week in the form of Sir Lindsay Hoyle, a parliamentarian from the Borough of Chorley in the County of Lancashire which happens to be Jack Catterall’s home district. “I have to question why the judges got it so wrong,” said MP Hoyle who is the Speaker of the House of Commons. “I have already sent a letter to the police.”
The Toney-Tiberi and Taylor-Catterall incidents had a lot in common. In both cases, the stakes were high. In both cases, there was drama as there always is when a Cinderella story is brewing and those that came to vicariously identify with the underdog as the fight progressed were denied the satisfaction of a storybook ending. And it mattered greatly that both fights were televised at an hour when a lot of people would be watching. (Toney-Tiberi aired on ABC at 5 pm ET on a Saturday.)
Josh Taylor won no new fans with his comments after the bout. “I don’t think there is any need for a rematch,” he said. “I won the second half of the fight. I took over and bossed him.” But the brunt of the fallout was born by judge Ian John-Lewis. His scorecard, 114-111 for the Tartan Tornado, tilted the heaviest toward the victor.
John-Lewis gave Taylor eight of the 12 rounds which included his 9-9 tally in Round 11 when Taylor was penalized one point for hitting Catterall a split second after the bell, a “make-up call” by referee Marcus McDonnell to atone for his questionable call in round nine when he took a point away from Catterall for excessive holding.
Ian John-Lewis won’t be judging another internationally important prizefight for quite some time. The British Boxing Board of Control, which classifies ring officials into tiers, has demoted him.
John-Lewis, a former pro boxer of no great distinction, is primarily known as a referee. He’s been doing it (judging and refereeing) since 1993 and has had some choice assignments. He’s been the third man in the ring for such notables as Ricky Hatton, Bernard Hopkins, Adonis Stevenson, and Vitali Klitschko, to name just four.
The title of Ian John-Lewis’s 2014 book, “I am the Referee,” details how he overcame his tough upbringing to become the first black man in Great Britain to become a world class referee. (It’s a curious book, full of self-serving testimonials, written in the first person yet credited to “author” John Heffernan who apparently did nothing more than turn on the tape recorder.)
So, the decision by the BBBofC is a double-whammy for poor Mr. John-Lewis, who won’t be getting any coveted assignments as a judge in the immediate future and will undoubtedly have a harder time peddling his book. But having said that, one could argue that he has been scapegoated, served up as a sacrificial lamb to appease the wolves.
When the final bell rang, signaling that the 12-round bout was going to the scorecards, history was solidly against Jack Catterall.
Years ago, there was a general feeling that a title ought not change hands on a close fight. The thinking was that the challenger had to “earn” it by winning convincingly, demonstrating his mastery, so to speak. Although Catterall scored the bout’s lone knockdown, he didn’t do that. The overwhelming consensus on social media is that he was robbed, but the feeling wasn’t unanimous. It was a messy fight and many of the rounds were close.
Catterall was up against it fighting a Scotsman in Glasgow. In no other sport does the home field advantage weigh so heavily in the handicapping equation. A world-weary fight manager at New York’s fabled Stillman’s Gym was overheard asking this question while talking on the pay phone to an out-of-town promoter: “If we win, can we get a draw?”
Catterall didn’t win, but he earned a lot of respect and his next fight will likely bring him the largest purse of his career. David Tiberi reportedly got $26,000 for his match with James Toney and was offered $140,000 for the rematch. (He spurned it and never fought again.)
True, whatever Catterall earns will be less than what he would have earned had he won the titles. And that is why it is so important that the judges get it right. Thousands, perhaps millions, of dollars in future earnings, life-changing money, can evaporate when a boxer is the victim of a rank decision.
Scribes who have used the word scandalous while referencing the Taylor-Catterall decision are over-stating matters. However, there was a recent scandalous event involving a boxing judge.
WBA judge Gloria Martinez Rizzo’s dumbfounding scorecard for the Aug. 7, 2021 fight in Minneapolis between Gabriel Maestre and Mykal Fox was truly an outrage and it appeared that we had seen the last of her when she was revealed to be an unabashed racist. But no, there she was back in action on Feb. 11, working five of seven bouts on a card in Miami.
WBA president Gilberto Mendoza had no recourse but to suspend her once her racist tweets surfaced. He said the suspension would be indefinite. As we have seen, that was a very liberal interpretation of “indefinite.”
To comment on this story in the Fight Forum CLICK HERE
Featured Articles
Early Results from Riyadh where Hamzah Sheeraz was Awarded a Gift Draw
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/58b10/58b10b05988d5450fa6b5d8e687aef11c201642e" alt="Early-Results-from-Riyadh-where-Hamza-Sheeraz-was-Awarded-a-Gift-Draw"
After two 6-round appetizers, British light heavyweights Joshua Buatsi and Callum Smith got the show rolling with a lusty 12-round skirmish. Things went south in the middle of the seven-fight main card when WBC middleweight champion Carlos Adames locked horns with challenger Hamzah Sheeraz. This was a drab fight owing to a milquetoast performance by the favored Sheeraz.
Heading in, the lanky six-foot-three Sheeraz, whose physique is mindful of a young Thomas Hearns, was undefeated in 21 fights. Having stopped five of his last six opponents in two rounds or less, the 25-year-old Englishman was touted as the next big thing in the middleweight division. However, he fought off his back foot the entire contest, reluctant to let his hands go, and Adames kept his title when the bout was scored a draw.
Sheeraz had the crowd in his corner and two of the judges scored the match with their ears. Their tallies were 115-114 for Sheeraz and 114-114. The third judge had it 118-110 for Adames, the 30-year old Dominican, now 24-1-1, who had Ismael Salas in his corner.
Ortiz-Madrimov
Super welterweight Vergil Ortiz Jr, knocked out his first 21 opponents, begging the question of how he would react when he finally faced adversity. He showed his mettle in August of last year when he went a sizzling 12 rounds with fellow knockout artist Serhii Bohachuk, winning a hard-fought decision. Tonight he added another feather in his cap with a 12-round unanimous decision over Ismail Madrimov, prevailing on scores of 117-111 and 115-113 twice.
Ortiz won by adhering tight to Robert Garcia’s game plan. The elusive Madrimov, who bounces around the ring like the energizer bunny, won the early rounds. But eventually Ortiz was able to cut the ring off and turned the tide in his favor by landing the harder punches. It was the second straight loss for Madrimov (10-2-1), a decorated amateur who had lost a close but unanimous decision to Terence Crawford in his previous bout.
Kabayel-Zhang
No heavyweight has made greater gains in the last 15 months than Agit Kabayel. The German of Kurdish descent, whose specialty is body punching, made his third straight appearance in Riyadh tonight and, like in the previous two, fashioned a knockout. Today, although out-weighed by more than 40 pounds, he did away with Zhilei “Big Bang” Zhang in the sixth round.
It didn’t start out well for Kabayel. The New Jersey-based, six-foot-six Zhang, a two-time Olympian for China, started fast and plainly won the opening round. Kabayel beat him to the punch from that point on, save for one moment when Zhang put him on the canvas with a straight left hand.
That happened in the fifth round, but by the end of the frame, the 41-year-old Zhang was conspicuously gassed. The end for the big fellow came at the 2:29 mark of round six when he couldn’t beat the count after crumbling to the canvas in a delayed reaction after taking a hard punch to his flabby midsection.
Kabayel remains undefeated at 26-0 (18 KOs). Zhang (27-3-1) hadn’t previously been stopped.
Smith-Buatsi
The all-British showdown between light heavyweights Joshua Buatsi and Callum Smith was a grueling, fan-friendly affair. A former 168-pound world title-holder, Smith, 34, won hard-earned unanimous decision, prevailing on scores of 115-113, 116-112, and a ludicrous 119-110.
There were no knockdowns, but Liverpool’s Smith, who advanced to 31-2 (22) finished the contest with a bad gash in the corner of his right eye. It was the first pro loss for Buatsi (19-1), an Olympic bronze medalist who entered the contest a small favorite and was the defending “interim” title-holder.
This contest was also a battle of wits between two of America’s most prominent trainers, Buddy McGirt (Smith) and Virgil Hunter (Buatsi).
Check back shortly for David Avila’s wrap-up of the last three fights.
Photo credit: Mark Robinson / Matchroom
To comment on this story in the Fight Forum CLICK HERE
Featured Articles
Cain Sandoval KOs Mark Bernaldez in the Featured Bout at Santa Ynez
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9d1cb/9d1cbf3b9e1cbd12d3e09e048c5b801de1127ccd" alt="Cain-Sandoval-KOs-Mark-Bernaldez-in-the-Featured-Bout-at-Santa-Ynez"
Northern California’s Cain Sandoval remained undefeated with a knockout win over Mark Bernaldez in a super lightweight battle on Friday on a 360 Promotions card.
Sandoval (15-0, 13 KOs) of Sacramento needed four rounds to figure out tough Filipino fighter Bernaldez (25-7, 14 KOs) in front of a packed crowd at Chumash Casino in Santa Ynez.
Bernaldez had gone eight rounds against Mexico’s very tough Oscar Duarte. He showed no fear for Sandoval’s reputed power and both fired bombs at each other from the second round on.
Things turned in favor of Sandoval when he targeted the body and soon had Bernaldez in retreat. It was apparent Sandoval had discovered a weakness.
In the beginning of the fourth Sandoval fired a stiff jab to the body that buckled Bernaldez but he did not go down. And when both resumed in firing position Sandoval connected with an overhand right and down went the Filipino fighter. He was counted out by referee Rudy Barragan at 34 seconds of the round.
“I’m surprised he took my jab to the body. I respect that. I have a knockout and I’m happy about that,” Sandoval said.
Other Bouts
Popular female fighter Lupe Medina (9-0) remained undefeated with a solid victory over the determined Agustina Vazquez (4-3-2) by unanimous decision after eight rounds in a minimumweight fight between Southern Californians.
Early on Vazquez gave Medina trouble disrupting her patter with solid jabs. And when Medina overloaded with combination punches, she was laced with counters from Vazquez during the first four rounds.
Things turned around in the fifth round as Medina used a jab to keep Vazquez at a preferred distance. And when she attacked it was no more than two-punch combination and maintaining a distance.
Vazquez proved determined but discovered clinching was not a good idea as Medina took advantage and overran her with blows. Still, Vazquez looked solid. All three judges saw it 79-73 for Medina.
A battle between Southern Californian’s saw Compton’s Christopher Rios (11-2) put on the pressure all eight rounds against Eastvale’s Daniel Barrera (8-1-1) and emerged the winner by majority decision in a flyweight battle.
It was Barrera’s first loss as a pro. He never could discover how to stay off the ropes and that proved his downfall. Neither fighter was knocked down but one judge saw it 76-76, and two others 79-73 for Rios.
In a welterweight fight Gor Yeritsyan (20-1,16 KOs) scorched Luis Ramos (23-7) with a 12-punch combination the sent him to the mat in the second round. After Ramos beat the count he was met with an eight punch volley and the fight was stopped at 2:11 of the second round by knockout.
Super feather prospect Abel Mejia (7-0, 5 KOs) floored Alfredo Diaz (9-12) in the fifth round but found the Mexican fighter to be very durable in their six-round fight. Mejia caught Diaz with a left hook in the fifth round for a knockdown. But the fight resumed with all three judges scoring it 60-53 for Mejia who fights out of El Modena, Calif.
To comment on this story in the Fight Forum CLICK HERE
Featured Articles
The Return of David Alaverdian
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d41ad/d41ad6cfce2c72af97b49ab7ff3b5a3fff536232" alt="The-Return-of-David-Alaverdian"
By TSS Special Correspondent David Harazduk — After David Alaverdian (8-0-1, 6 KOs) scored a gritty victory against a tough Nicaraguan journeyman named Enrique Irias, his plans suddenly changed. The flashy flyweight from Nahariya, Israel hoped to face even tougher opposition and then challenge for a world title within a year or so. But a prolonged illness forced David to rip up the script.
The Irias fight was over 22 months ago. On Saturday, Feb. 22, Alaverdian will be making his first appearance in the ring since that win when he faces veteran road warrior Josue “Zurdo” Morales (31-16-4, 13 KOs) at the Westgate Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas. It’s the fifth promotion by Las Vegas attorney Stephen Reid whose inaugural card was at this venue on Feb. 13, 2020.
“I’m excited to come back,” Alaverdian declared.
During his preparation for Irias two years ago, Alaverdian felt fatigue after a routine six-round sparring session. “It was on April 1, 2023, about ten days before my fight. It felt like an April Fool’s joke,” he said. He came down with a sore throat, a headache, and congestion. He soon developed trouble breathing. At first, he thought his seasonal asthma had flared up, but his condition soon worsened. No matter what he did, Alaverdian could no longer take deep breaths. Fatigue continued to plague him. His heart constantly raced. Instead of breathing from his diaphragm, he was breathing from his chest. He sought out numerous doctors in the United States and in Israel.
His symptoms were finally diagnosed as Dysfunctional Breathing (DB). DB is a condition that can stem from stress and is often misdiagnosed. Its symptoms include dyspnea and tachycardia, both of which David experienced.
While receiving treatment, the Vegas-based pro went back to Israel where he coached aspiring fighters. “David’s influence on Israeli boxing is amazing, because he shows we can succeed in a big business even though we come from a small country,” said another undefeated Israeli flyweight, 20-year-old Yonatan Landman (7-0, 7 KOs). “A lot more Israelis are going to dare to succeed.”
Landman was able to work with Alaverdian during David’s return to Israel. “He is a great guy and a friend,” Landman said. “He has a lot of willingness to help, share his knowledge, and help you move forward.”
Alaverdian finally started to feel like he could compete again eight months ago. He won last year’s Israeli national amateur championship and competed in Olympic qualifiers. Now, he’s preparing to fight as a professional once again. “He doesn’t mention anything about [his breathing issues] like he did before,” his coach Cedric Ferguson said about this camp. “He’s been working like there’s no issue at all.”
It has been a whirlwind week for the 31-year-old Alaverdian. In addition to putting the finishing touches on his preparation ahead of Saturday’s comeback fight, David got married on Tuesday. His mom came over from Israel for the wedding and will stay for the fight. “It’s a good distraction,” David said of this week’s significant events. “It helps me. That way I don’t have to focus on the fight all day.”
Josue Morales, a 32 year old from Houston, hopes to play spoiler on Saturday. The crafty southpaw has never been stopped during his 52-fight career. “He’s a seasoned guy with a lot of experience,” Alaverdian said of Morales. “He knows how to move around the ring and is more of a technical boxer. He’s a tough opponent for someone who has been out of the ring for two years.”
A win Saturday night would complete a monumental week for David Alaverdian, both in and out of the ring, repairing the once-shredded script.
Doors open at the Westgate fight arena at 6:30 pm. The first bout goes at 7:00. Seven fights are scheduled including an 8-round female fight between Las Vegas light flyweight Yadira Bustillos and Argentine veteran Tamara Demarco.
NOTE: Author David Harazduk has run The Jewish Boxing Blog since 2010. You can find him at Twitter/X @JewishBoxing and Instagram.
To comment on this story in the Fight Forum CLICK HERE
-
Featured Articles1 week ago
Results and Recaps from Madison Square Garden where Keyshawn Davis KO’d Berinchyk
-
Featured Articles3 weeks ago
Hall of Fame Boxing Writer Michael Katz (1939-2025) Could Wield His Pen like a Stiletto
-
Featured Articles3 weeks ago
Claressa Shields Powers to Undisputed Heavyweight Championship
-
Featured Articles1 week ago
Vito Mielnicki Hopes to Steal the Show on Friday at Madison Square Garden
-
Featured Articles4 weeks ago
Najee Lopez Steps up in Class and Wins Impressively at Plant City
-
Featured Articles3 weeks ago
Bakhodir Jalolov Returns on Thursday in Another Disgraceful Mismatch
-
Featured Articles2 weeks ago
With Valentine’s Day on the Horizon, let’s Exhume ex-Boxer ‘Machine Gun’ McGurn
-
Featured Articles2 weeks ago
More ‘Dances’ in Store for Derek Chisora after out-working Otto Wallin in Manchester